6/29/2002

Central Park Horses

Rant

From www.centralpark.org:

THINGS TO DO
Horse-Drawn Carriage Rides
Year-round
One of the most romantic and popular ways to see Central Park is from a horse-drawn carriage. Visitors enjoy this year-round, even during the winter months. The carriages can be found lined up along Central Park South (59th Street) between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, at the southern end of Central Park across from the Plaza Hotel. Rides cost $34 for the first 20 minutes and $54 for a 45 to 50 minute tour.

The idea for my first rant came about when I was walking down Central Park South and Central Park West in New York City a couple of weeks ago. It was after 8:00, but it was still pretty light outside. All along these two streets were horse-drawn carriages, some with drivers, some without. The drivers who were there were for the most part sleeping, and a few of the horses looked quite unhappy to be there. One kept stamping his feet, others were looking around all over the place. One horse had to deal with a man who didn’t look like he belonged there and seemed to be bugging the horse. Now, I’ll see horse-drawn carriages all the time, since I work close to Central Park. However, seeing all these horses in a row seemed very sad to me.

It isn’t natural for horses to be tethered up to a vehicle that is used only for luxury. I can understand better a horse used for helping out on a farm and such, but these horses are used for the sole purpose of transporting people, usually tourists, around in a fashion that isn’t needed. The rest of us walk or take the bus, etc. and there are many tour buses around Manhattan (one of them stops right outside the building where I work). Why can’t more people take these forms of transportation instead? They cost about the same, and with a tour bus you even get someone who points out the sights to you.

The treatment of these animals has got to stop. We should not have to exploit other beings for our own entertainment. Just from looking at the horses along Central Park, I’ve noticed that people try to interact with the animals all the time. Imagine just standing there and having crowds of people bugging you, trying to pet your head, and getting mad when you ignore them. Well, that’s exactly what’s happening to these horses. There is a pouch in back of the horses so they can evacuate when they need to, so that you wouldn’t have to walk through horse feces everywhere you turned. However, the horses’ tails naturally fall in this pouch and probably pick up who knows what. Because of the placement of the pouch and the carriage above, the tail doesn’t have much space to move around.

One way to stop this is NOT TO TAKE THE RIDES. Obviously, if no one wants to aid in the exploitation of other animals in this fashion, the carriage companies will have to try something else, like treat their horses better.

Rave

These are only the things that I noticed. I knew nothing of what happens to these horses before and after they work for the day. So I looked on the Internet and found some interesting sites to read.

One of these sites is Project Equus, a horse protection organization in Colorado. To look specifically at the horse-drawn carriage issue, click on F.Y.I., then Carriage Horses. The entire site is worth looking at, however. This site gave me a lot of information on the medical side of what happens to these horses, the side that regular people wouldn’t see. It’s not a “poor us” site which tries to elicit your sympathy by showing animals with big eyes who “need your help”. They give the facts, which are so appalling that you can’t help but do something about it. They also give excellent suggestions as to how to end this problem. For instance, rallies against carriage companies are worse than the original mistreatment of the horses. Instead, we can try to “educate lawmakers about equine health.” (from www.projectequus.org)

Another site to look at is Red Wings, a horse sanctuary in California. This site does have pictures, but the pictures are only there to help illustrate what happens to horses all over the country. To look at their page on carriage horses, click on Equine Issues, then Carriage Horses at the bottom of the page. Unfortunately, the picture for this page won’t load properly. This entire site is worth looking into as well.

If you don’t want to get into a letter writing campaign to get lawmakers interested, which I agree is a daunting task, you can donate to these two sites. Tell them that you want to stop this, so they know there are people interested in this issue.

And if you think that I only presented one side of this story, a search on Google for “horse drawn central park” mainly showed me sites inviting me to partake of the wonderful carriage rides in New York City’s Central Park. These are the only two sites I found in the first 200 pages that said anything of substance.

One Response to “Central Park Horses”

  1. Anita Gerami Says:

    its so obvious you never actually spoke to a Carriage driver,or its owner.This business is highly regulated and monitered,plus all the nyc stables have a wonderful communication with the health dept and aspca.As a major stable owner,we fo what we do,cause we love it,and our horses are our main focus why we love it. Business has tripled in the past 2 yrs,and people love and enjoy,our business,more and more. So please take a moment ,to talk to our staff,and i think you will have adifferent outlook.

Leave a Reply